America Did Not Rescue Chibok Girls -Intl Human Rights Activist Disproves Diaspora Media Publication

Fifty-seven of them escaped over the next few months, but most were never heard from again.

The families of the kidnapped were devastated on account of this tragedy that stunned the world.

The stories of the girls and the anguish of their parents; chronicles the rise of Boko Haram and the Nigerian government’s inept response caught the attention of the world’s media and the international community.

The Chibok / CIA controversy

An international Human Rights Lawyer, Mr. Emmanuel Ogebe, meanwhile, has debunked claims by an American author that American security forces brought back Chibok Girls in Nigeria, as claimed in a new book.

Mr. Ogebe made the remarks in the first in a series of the Chibok Girls Special 10th anniversary report released on April 6, 2024, by the US Nigeria Law Group, a social cum legal action group.

The reports exposed monumental intelligence failure and deception in the world’s longest-running mass kidnap.

In the report entitled “America Did Not Bring Back Our Girls, despite new book’s claims, 10 years later – Part 1“, Ogebe spoke on the “world’s longest Chibok schoolgirl mass abduction that spawned the global #bbog”.

He wrote: “Seven International aid workers were killed in Gaza this Easter Monday. The world acknowledged it immediately.

“The UN Security Council had passed a ceasefire resolution just a week before.

“Yet, though Boko Haram terrorists bombed the UN building in Nigeria in 2011 killing 25, including UN diplomats, they were not sanctioned till May 2014 – weeks after infamously abducting almost 300 Chibok schoolgirls.

“Now, as the world’s attention has turned to the latest flashtag, Gaza, as it desperately should and must, almost 10 years later, a new book credits the US with recovering 30 girls, which it didn’t.

“This titillating nugget was found in the new book “The Sisterhood: The Secret History of Women at the CIA” by Liza Mundy:

“Her third posting was Nigeria, where in April 2014, 276 female students had been kidnapped from a Christian boarding school in Chibok by the Islamic terrorist group Boko Haram…

“Working with the British and French, they hoped to get all the girls in one fell swoop, but some had been married off to fighters and were reluctant or unable to leave their babies, at least not right away.

“But they did get thirty at one time, and others, in ones and twos, trickling, terrified, from the thick forest, clutching the offspring of the men they’d been given to,” says the book about “Molly” a CIA operative.

““Women have worked at the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) from its origins in World War Il through the present (and) books have been written about the U.S.’s main foreign spy agency, but not from the perspective of women,” Jo Freeman says in her review of “The Sisterhood: The Secret History of Women at the CIA”.

Ogebe counters Liza Mundy

“As heartwarming as this sounds, and I truly want it to be true but there simply isn’t much support for the veracity of these claims.

“As a top global authority on the world’s longest-running mass abduction, we know the initial 2014 escapes of 57 schoolgirls documented by the Christian Association of Nigeria in Chibok in concert with ThisDay Newspapers and former UK PM Gordon Brown

“The miraculous escape of Amina Ali #127 in 2016 facilitated by her community’s youth volunteer as documented by my team and cited in the book, The Chibok Girls: The Boko Haram Kidnappings and Islamist Militancy in Nigeria (Paperback) then, there is the watershed work.

Another literary work on the Chibok escapade, Beneath the Tamarind Tree: A Story of Courage, Family, and the Lost Schoolgirls of Boko Haram” was written by Isha Sesay, a former CNN anchor.

Sesay witnessed firsthand the historic home return of the first batch of 21 girls ransomed in 2016 to Chibok fleetingly at Christmas.

Ogebe noted that the numbers and timelines do not add up with Molly’s CIA story.

“It was a combination of the world’s elation at Amina Ali’s seismic resurrection from the depths and CNN’s Buhari regime-shaming world exclusive proof of life video that forced the freedom of 21 girls (not 30) and not the CIA (thank you).

“And oh, at least 80 schoolgirls are still missing, BTW, please, CIA.

“Maybe let’s revise that contemporary history first after we’ve actually brought back the girls after 10 years.

Not before,” he added.

Associated Press uncovers mass deception

An Associated Press’ report on this epic account dug from the archives entitled “Free from Boko Haram, Nigeria’s Chibok girls are kept silent”, written by veteran Michelle Faul, reads:

“She was found wandering in a forest, the first of the nearly 300 Chibok schoolgirls kidnapped by Boko Haram to escape on her own and reach freedom.

That was in May.

Since then, Amina Ali Nkeki has been sequestered by Nigeria’s intelligence agency, embraced just once by her family months ago.

Some say Nigeria’s government is keeping the young woman silent because it doesn’t want her telling the world about military blunders in the fight against the Islamic extremist group, or about her desire to be reunited with the father of her child — a detained former Boko Haram commander.

“I worry, sometimes, that I don’t know if she is alive or dead,” her mother, Binta Ali Nkeki, sobbed during an exclusive telephone interview with The Associated Press from her remote northeastern village of Mbalala.

She said she hasn’t seen her daughter since July.

Sunday marks 1,000 days since the Chibok schoolgirls were abducted together from a government boarding school in April 2014.

Most of them remain in captivity.

The few who have been freed, like Amina, have found themselves not completely free.

The mass kidnapping horrified the world and brought Boko Haram international attention.

The failure of Nigeria’s former government to act quickly to free the girls sparked a global Bring Back Our Girls movement.

Even U.S. first lady Michelle Obama posted a photo with its logo on social media.

Amina was the first of the kidnapped girls to escape on her own.

Months later, in October, the government negotiated the release of 21 Chibok girls.

Another girl was freed in November in an army raid on an extremist camp in the Sambisa Forest.

On Thursday, one more was found during military interrogations of Boko Haram suspects, along with the baby she had given birth to in captivity.

When Amina’s mother heard last month that “freed” girls would be allowed to come home for Christmas, she borrowed money to reach Chibok, the town where their former boarding school is located.

She was welcomed by the 21 girls, who tried to reassure her that her daughter was “fine, in good health,” even though she had not been allowed to accompany them.

Human rights groups and lawyers have criticized Nigeria’s treatment of the freed girls, who are held in Abuja, the capital, nearly 900 kilometers (560 miles) from Chibok. The government says the girls are getting medical attention, trauma counseling and rehabilitation.

Officials in the government and the presidency did not respond to requests for comment, following a familiar pattern.

People who have spoken to the freed girls say they have stories the government does not want told, including that three Chibok girls were killed during Nigerian Air Force bombings of Boko Haram camps.

Amina, who is believed to be at least 20 though her uneducated mother says she has no idea, has insisted that her child’s father is a victim, like herself, who was kidnapped by Boko Haram and forced to fight for the insurgents.

Binta says that when her daughter was rescued — hunters found Amina, her 4-month-old baby girl and the father in a forest — she said she didn’t want to go back to school.

But her mother and brother, Noah, persuaded her to take up Nigerian President Muhammadu Buhari’s promise to give her the best education possible.

“They told her that soon she will be starting school,” Noah Ali Nkeki told the AP in an interview.

He got the news in a rare phone call from his sister on Thursday, the first time he had heard from her in three months.

He cannot call her.

Officials call him using a blocked number and then put Amina on the line.

The girl’s mother doesn’t get to speak to her because she doesn’t own a cellphone and reception in her village is poor.

“I don’t know what the government is trying to do. They have had her now for seven months,” Noah said.

Binta, a gaunt woman whose eyes mirror the pain of a hard life and whose hands are rough from farming, was widowed five years ago.

Eleven of her children have died, in childbirth or soon afterward. Amina and Noah are all she has.

“I wonder how my only grandchild is doing.

“Do you think she’s walking by now?” she said of Amina’s daughter, Safia.

Binta was suicidal after her daughter’s kidnapping, community leaders have told the AP.

There were reports Boko Haram threatened to sell the kidnapped girls into slavery, marry them off to fighters and force them to convert to Islam.

Chibok is a Christian enclave in mainly Muslim northern Nigeria.

Binta rallied after she got a message from Amina in 2015.

In Chibok, two male Boko Haram fighters accompanied by a teenage girl carrying ammunition came across an elderly woman too feeble to flee.

The girl, speaking the Chibok language that the fighters could not understand, told the woman, “I am Amina. My mother’s name is Binta in the village of Mbalala. Please tell her you saw me.”

The elderly woman described the encounter to community leaders, who worried that the “proof of life” message might be too much for Binta to bear.” [End]

Ogebe slams Chibok community leaders

The Human rights lawyer, Ogebe, stepped in.

“If I had a daughter who was missing and she tried to send a message to me, l’d be very upset if someone withheld it.

“Amina tried to reach out, let’s help her complete the effort,” he counseled.

When Amina was freed, she and her family were flown to Abuja, where TV cameras and photographers documented Buhari welcoming her at the presidential mansion.

That happened again with the 21 freed girls.

The girls needed trauma counseling and medical care, not exposure to the media, Human Rights Watch said at the time.

On Christmas Day, the freed girls visiting Chibok did not get to see their parents.

They were kept in the house of a local legislator until Borno State Gov. Kashim Shettima arrived to “present” them to their parents the next day.

Witnesses said the girls were angry they were prevented from going home and to their church’s Christmas service.

Shettima’s spokesman, Isa Gusau, denied that account, which came from some of the parents.

“I am not sure they were denied access to their parents because that was the essence of them being taken to Chibok in the first place.

“If you say their movements were restricted for security reasons and for their safety, I think that makes sense,” he told the AP.

Yakubu Nkeki, chairman of the Chibok association of parents of the kidnapped girls and who is not related to Amina, said the Department of State Security intelligence agents who accompanied the girls deemed it unsafe for them to visit parents in outlying villages.

But those with homes in Chibok town were not allowed to stay with their families either.

Amina’s mother, despite her tears, still has some faith in Nigeria’s actions.

“Anything that the government wants to do with Amina, I have no problem with that.

“But I just want to see my daughter with my own eyes,” she said.

On Friday, the Bring Back Out Girls movement criticized the failure to free the 196 girls still missing, saying:

“[It] is justifiably worried that the Nigerian government has once again relapsed to the same complacency, lethargy, and inertia that has been recurrent on this tragedy.”

Amnesty International also called for the government to “redouble its efforts,” warning the abductions could constitute war crimes.

Associated Press writers Haruna Umar in Maiduguri, Ibrahim Abdulaziz in Yola and Bashir Adigun in Abuja, Nigeria, contributed to the report.

PS: At the time, 196 girls were still missing but based on the graph below over 100 of those are now back largely from the second batch ransom of 81 girls in 2017.

 

Ogebe added: “Lastly, I was General Buhari’s Public Enemy Number One in Diaspora long before Nnamdi Kanu.

“I was targeted by multiple agencies of the Nigerian state including NIA, DIA and NSA all reporting to Buhari directly on me.

“I even sued his regime, but the Bible says you must give the devil his due.

“The ransoming of 102 Chibok was done by his administration not by the USA.

“If the USA wants to help, there are still 80-90 more Chibok girls unaccounted for,” he concluded.

See below activist’s timeline of girls’ returns:

About Emmanuel Ogebe

Emmanuel Ogebe, Esq, is a prominent US-based international human rights lawyer in Washington exiled to America after abduction and torture by Dictator Abacha for protesting the assassination of pro-democracy icon Kudirat Abiola over the Nigerian 1993 election.

Mr. Ogebe played a role in shaping US Congressional and foreign policy in Nigeria’s quest for a stable democracy.

Mr. Ogebe has been a guest speaker at university campuses across the US and on radio and TV programs around the world, e.g. CNN, Fox, Al Jazeera, BBC, the Geneva Summit, the United Nations, the World Bank, the Canadian Parliament etc.

His decades of advocacy led to:

1. the naming of Kudirat corner by Nigeria house in New York (1998),
2. the US designations of Boko Haram as a foreign terrorist organization (2013),
3. the US designations of Nigeria as a Country of Particular Concern (2020),
4. International Criminal Court Prosecutor’s determination of crimes against humanity in Nigeria (2020), amongst others.

Ogebe was consulted by Presidents Clinton (2000) and Bush’s Administrations (2003) on their visits to Nigeria.

He currently serves as Special Counsel for the Justice for Jos Project, a pro bono initiative of his firm, which has worked for 15 years to garner international attention to the horrific crimes against humanity in Nigeria on behalf of persecuted minorities.

He provides assistance to survivors, widows and orphans, refugees & IDPs of terror.

Mr Ogebe is also a recipient of US President‘s Bronze Volunteer Award for his pro bono work serving in northern Nigeria, the “Hero of the Year” Award by the Darfur Women Action Group and awards from Diaspora groups in Maryland and New Jersey as well as official US State and local recognitions in Florida, Arkansas and New Jersey amongst others.

Emmanuel Ogebe is a formidable Nigerian human rights lawyer in Diaspora advocating in multiple continents including Europe, North America, Asia, Africa, Australia and the Middle East.

His dogged defense of a Nigerian citizen trafficked abroad and sentenced to death pro bono for 15 years led to victory at Indonesia’s Supreme Court which freed him in December 2023.